ESG: The challenges faced by front-office and enterprise risk functions

In light of emerging legislation centred around ESG, financial firms must employ robust risk strategies to address the multifaceted challenges posed by the ESG landscape.
27 Nov, 2023

In an environment characterised by Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations and the pressing challenges of climate change (Figure 1), the roles of front office and enterprise risk functions within financial organisations have taken on a profound new significance. These functions stand at the nexus of opportunity and responsibility, entrusted with navigating the complexities of ESG integration and climate change mitigation.

The evolving regulatory landscape, epitomised by the PRA’s SS3/19 and the developing DP/CP rules, further underscores the importance of integrating ESG considerations into risk management practices, marking a paradigm shift in risk assessment methodologies. This blog summarises the dynamic interplay between the front office and enterprise risk functions, exploring how collaboration, data-driven insights, and strategic alignment are pivotal in addressing the multifaceted challenges posed by the ESG landscape.

Figure 1: Historical and predicted mean temperature difference (Source: Met Office)

Front office and enterprise risk functions

In the era of ESG and climate change, financial organisations must incorporate ESG factors into investments and employ robust risk strategies, collaborating with the use of advanced analytics to navigate successful ESG integration and climate change mitigation. Embracing roles as responsible stewards paves the way for a resilient future.

Front office challenges

Incorporating ESG factors: Front office teams are at the forefront of investment decision-making and must recognise the importance of ESG metrics whilst understanding how they impact financial performance. Sophisticated models must be developed to accurately assess ESG risks and opportunities, ensuring that sustainable considerations are seamlessly integrated into investment strategies.

Data availability and quality: The availability of reliable and standardised ESG data poses a significant challenge. The quest for comprehensive and accurate data is essential for generating valuable insights that guide investment choices.

ESG disclosure and reporting: The lack of consistent ESG disclosure standards and reporting frameworks complicates the task of comparing and evaluating ESG performance across companies.  A standardised reporting framework would enhance transparency and facilitate more informed decision-making.

Investor expectations and preferences: Investor expectations have undergone a transformation, with a growing demand for ESG integration and transparency. For the front office, integrating non-financial factors into investment decisions has become an integral aspect of meeting investor demands and ensuring long-term success when navigating this evolving landscape.

A sophisticated risk modelling framework is required to understand how different ESG factors interact and influence each other.

Enterprise risk challenges

Identifying and assessing ESG risks: The emergence of climate change and ESG factors introduces a new spectrum of risks that must be identified and assessed by enterprise risk functions. From physical risks like extreme weather events to transitional risks stemming from policy changes, and reputational risks linked to public perception, a comprehensive risk assessment strategy is essential.

Modelling complex interactions: Enterprise risk functions face the challenge of modelling and analysing complex, interconnected ESG risks to anticipate potential systemic risks. A sophisticated risk modelling framework is required to understand how different ESG factors interact and influence each other.

Scenario analysis and stress testing: Given the inherent uncertainties tied to climate change and ESG, conducting scenario analysis and stress testing becomes a vital risk management tool.  In the face of evolving ESG challenges, Quantifi supports dedicated ESG scenarios alongside traditional market regime, sector and geographical stress testing.

Regulatory compliance: Keeping abreast of the ever-changing ESG-related regulations and ensuring compliance is essential to mitigate the risk of financial penalties and safeguard an organisation’s reputation.

Adapting to PRA SS3/19 and evolving DP/CP regulations

The regulatory landscape is evolving to reflect the growing importance of ESG factors in the financial industry (Figure 2). Regulatory bodies have responded with guidelines and rules to ensure a responsible and resilient financial ecosystem. Notably, the Prudential Regulation Authority’s (PRA) Supervisory Statement SS3/19, coupled with the evolving Disclosure Paper (DP) and Consultation Paper (CP) rules from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), underscore the need for an evolved risk appetite framework that aligns with ESG considerations, reflecting a new era of responsible finance.

The PRA’s SS3/19 marks a pivotal step towards integrating ESG factors into the risk management strategies of financial institutions. The statement highlights the necessity for firms to assess and manage both physical and transition risks associated with climate change and other ESG issues, signifying a paradigm shift in risk assessment and management.

Figure 2 – ESG current strategy priorities (Source: FCA)

The FCA’s DP/CP rules enhance ESG disclosure transparency, empowering informed investor decisions and encouraging sustainable practices amid rising stakeholder expectations for accountability to ESG principles.

Organisations must reassess risk processes, requiring a profound understanding of how environmental, social, and governance impacts risk profiles to integrate ESG factors. For example, climate change poses physical risks (e.g., property damage) and transition risks (e.g., regulatory changes). Quantifying and integrating these factors into risk models is crucial for a comprehensive view of vulnerabilities.

Collaboration across departments is another critical aspect of evolving risk appetite, enabling organisations to identify interdependencies and potential cascading effects that could arise from ESG risks, leading to more robust risk assessments and mitigation strategies.

Quantifi: Support for ESG

With Quantifi, clients can leverage pre-built stress tests or create customised scenarios reflecting ESG risk factor metrics. With access to real-time, historical, and custom reporting, you can create a single view of your ESG risk. Full transparency is achieved with interactive drilldown, slicing and aggregation across all data to accurately monitor risk on a portfolio and incremental basis to evaluate portfolio impact. Quantifi also supports ESG ratings and other related criteria for custom credit scoring to allow rapid and systematic incorporation of entity exposures for direct lending, counterparty credit exposures and XVA.

Let's talk!

Speak with one of our solution experts